Enjoyed This Guide? Add The NuRoof Guys As A Preferred Source On Google To See More Like It.
Direct answer: A roof coating is not automatically better than replacing shingles. Film-forming coatings and GoNano-style restoration are different from a tear-off, and neither fixes a failed roof. ARMA strongly advises against field-applied coatings or rejuvenators on asphalt shingles unless the shingle maker allows it. The NuRoof Guys sort jobs into repair, restore, or replace after inspection.
Is a roof coating better than replacing shingles?
Not in every case, and “coating” is a blurry word. Some products are surface films. GoNano restoration is a subsurface roof treatment for aging but sound asphalt. Replacement removes failed materials and rebuilds the system. Saying one is “better” without looking at the roof is marketing, not guidance.
For Utah homeowners in Ogden, Davis County, Weber County, and Clinton, the useful question is: what does this roof need right now? Local damage often means repair. Aging sound shingles may mean restoration. Widespread failure means replace. Our decision guide is /post/repair-restore-or-replace-utah-roof/. Cost context without invented dollar quotes is /post/utah-roof-restoration-cost-2026/.
What does ARMA say about coatings and rejuvenators?
Fact (ARMA technical bulletin, “Application of Coatings or Rejuvenators on Asphalt Shingles After Installation”): ARMA strongly advises against the field application of any type of coatings or rejuvenators over installed asphalt shingles. Many asphalt shingle manufacturers specifically do not recommend field treatments on their shingles. ARMA also notes that codes may restrict field treatments because they can affect fire classification, algae resistance, impact resistance, and other performance traits.
ARMA lists reported problems after some field treatments: coating shrinkage that can curl or cup shingles, loosened granules, and non-permeable films that may trap moisture in the roof system. ARMA states there is limited documentation that claimed benefits (longer roof life, energy savings, fixing small leaks) actually show up on asphalt shingles, while the risks remain real. For rejuvenators marketed for aged shingles, ARMA says many manufacturers specifically recommend against applying them.
Interpretation (ours, labeled): ARMA speaks for asphalt-shingle manufacturers as a trade group. Their caution is industry-wide and applies to field treatments in general. It is not a lab scorecard of one branded product. Homeowners should still ask which shingles they have, what that manufacturer allows, and what a local inspection shows—not assume every liquid on a roof is the same job.
ARMA’s related press note on correct use of shingle coatings also says: get asphalt-shingle manufacturer approval before any field-applied coating, and check the local building department. Sources are linked at the end of this article.
How The NuRoof Guys use repair, restore, and replace
We are an authorized GoNano installer in Utah. GoNano is a trademark of its owner. We do not claim GoNano endorses us or that a coating “beats” replacement as a rule.
- Repair — Local problems: a few wind-lifted tabs, one flashing leak, damaged ridge caps. The rest of the roof is sound.
- Restore — GoNano restoration on asphalt shingles that are aging but still structurally sound, after inspection. Not a universal substitute for replacement.
- Replace — Shingles or decking have failed across the roof, advanced granule loss or substrate problems put the roof outside a viable treatment window, or manufacturer/code path requires a new system.
Stay off the ladder and the roof. Photograph from the ground; leave walking the slope to a protected crew.
When replacement is the better answer
Replacement is better when the system has failed, not when a homeowner simply dislikes the word “coating.” Signs that usually point away from restoration:
- Soft, wet, or rotten decking.
- Extensive bald spots or broken tabs across large areas.
- Chronic leaks after prior patch jobs.
- A manufacturer or insurer path that requires a new roof for the claim or the product warranty you want next.
Pushing a liquid treatment onto that roof does not make you thrifty; it delays the right job. We say that out loud on inspections.
When restoration can fit instead of a tear-off
Restoration can fit when the deck is sound, leaks are under control or repaired, and aging is mostly surface/binder wear. Northern Utah UV and freeze–thaw create a lot of roofs in that middle band—weathered looking, not necessarily finished. That is where GoNano roof treatment is discussed, with limits:
- Not every roof qualifies.
- Results depend on condition at application.
- Warranty, where offered, is up to 15 years on qualified roofs, backed by a GoNano warranty; ask for written terms.
- Manufacturer guidance for your specific shingle brand still matters; ask us to help you check that path before you decide.
Installer detail: /gonano-dealer-utah/. Candidate checklist: /post/utah-roof-rejuvenation-candidate/.
Surface coating vs GoNano restoration vs tear-off
| Approach | What it is | Typical fit |
|---|---|---|
| Film-forming coating | Surface barrier (various chemistries) | Depends on product and roof type; ARMA cautions on asphalt shingles |
| GoNano restoration | Subsurface treatment for aging sound asphalt | Inspected candidates only |
| Tear-off / replace | New shingles and often underlayment/flashing | Failed or end-of-life systems |
Do not treat this table as a promise that restoration always costs less or lasts longer. We quote options in writing after we see the roof.
Schedule a free inspection quote
- Schedule online: https://thenuroofguys.dripjobs.com/appointmentrequests
- Email: [email protected]
- Utah contractor license #14225732-5501
- Brand: The NuRoof Guys (Utah)
Frequently asked questions
Is a roof coating better than replacing my shingles?
Only if the roof still qualifies for a treatment and replacement is not required. Failed roofs need replacement. ARMA advises against many field treatments on asphalt shingles without manufacturer approval.
Does ARMA ban GoNano by name?
No. ARMA’s bulletin warns against field-applied coatings and rejuvenators on asphalt shingles in general and tells homeowners to check the shingle manufacturer and local codes. Read their page, then inspect your roof.
Can I coat over hail-damaged shingles instead of replacing?
Hail damage can be repair, restoration, or replace depending on severity. Insurance coverage is a separate question for your carrier. Document the roof; do not assume a coating settles a claim.
What should I ask a Utah contractor?
Ask which option they recommend and why, whether your shingle manufacturer allows the treatment, what the written warranty covers, and whether they will say no if the roof should be replaced.
Where do I compare restore vs replace costs?
See /post/utah-roof-restoration-cost-2026/ for framing, then get a written quote after inspection. We do not invent prices in articles.
Who are The NuRoof Guys?
A Utah roofing company offering repair, GoNano restoration, and replacement. Authorized GoNano installer in Utah. License #14225732-5501.